Palestine is Still the Issue

Share this post

Twitter is censoring reporting on Ukrainian Nazis on the pretext of "abusive behavior"

asawinstanley.substack.com

Twitter is censoring reporting on Ukrainian Nazis on the pretext of "abusive behavior"

I've been locked out of my Twitter account over this post.

Asa Winstanley
Mar 11, 2022
39
18
Share this post

Twitter is censoring reporting on Ukrainian Nazis on the pretext of "abusive behavior"

asawinstanley.substack.com
The photos I attached to my banned tweet.

Twitter has locked me out of my account and has prevented me from posting the following tweet, which they claim is “abusive.” They are also threatening to suspend my account altogether if I post similar things in the future.

Please share this post on Twitter to push back against the company’s censorship

Share

I attached the above photos to my tweet. Although they did not initially say as much, one day on, Twitter are now claiming the tweet was “abusive”.

As you can see, the post is entirely factual, accurate and sourced, and not at all abusive.

I obtained the photos either from mainstream reporting or from primary sources — NATO’s official Twitter account, Tarrant’s manifesto (which is available online) and even Ukraine’s foreign ministry itself.

Twitter avatar for @MFA_Ukraine
MFA of Ukraine 🇺🇦 @MFA_Ukraine
According to the latest survey, more than 15% of the regular Ukrainian army are women. Number of those who defend Ukraine now in a different way is impossible to count. Thank you! 💙💛
Image
Image
Image
Image
6:43 AM ∙ Mar 8, 2022
15,693Likes2,772Retweets

Yet Twitter’s automated systems have apparently deemed the tweet in violation of their rules — although they did not initially specify which rule, and have still not explained how the post violates their rules on “abuse”.

Twitter’s rules appear not to apply to NATO or the Ukrainian Ministry of Foreign Affairs.

The post has been hidden by Twitter and replaced with the above notice.

My Twitter account (which has almost 59,000 followers) is currently still viewable, but I can no longer post new tweets. Indeed, I have been locked out of even viewing anything on Twitter while signed in. Every time I sign in, I get the notice at the top of this post, demanding I delete the tweet and acknowledge it as being in violation of their rules.

Thank you for reading Palestine is Still the Issue. This post is public so feel free to share it.

Share

I appealed Twitter’s (apparently automatic) lock of my account:

That was yesterday.

Today, even as I was writing this post, I received a second email from Twitter in which they say my account “will remain limited for the allotted time” due to what they claim are “violations of the Twitter Rules, specifically our rules against abusive behavior.”

Are Twitter therefore claiming I have “abused” NATO or “abused” Nazis by posting this completely factual, non-abusive tweet?

Their email today claiming “abusive behavior” does not directly address my tweet. But it does cite the same case number as I was given when I lodged my appeal. As such, they appear to have rejected my appeal.

The lock on my account happened literally instantly as I posted the tweet — I got an email notice right away. This is the reason I suspect it must have been an automated ban.

Triggered by what, I have not been told.

Unfortunately, this censorious lack of transparency is a growing problem with Twitter in recent years — one of the unaccountable Silicon Valley monopolies which dominate and control what are in effect de facto public spaces.

According to China podcaster Carl Zha, researcher and analyst Brian Berletic has had his Twitter account suspended altogether, after posting another image of a Ukrainian solider wearing the Nazi Black Sun symbol on his uniform.

Twitter avatar for @CarlZha
Carl Zha @CarlZha
Hi @TwitterSupport, Why did you suspend researcher and analyst @brian_berletic over this tweet???
Image
Image
4:02 AM ∙ Mar 9, 2022
3,671Likes1,117Retweets

Since it’s now been a day with no action by Twitter to reverse this ban I’m asking you, my readers, to please share this article all over social media, especially on Twitter.

Please tweet demanding that @Twitter, @TwitterSafety and @TwitterComms reverse this censorship and allow the tweet.

I would prefer not to be forced into the position of clicking “delete” on that tweet — which Twitter claims would constitute an “acknowledgement that your Tweet violated the Twitter Rules”.

As far as I can see it did not.

Share this article

Can we can put enough public pressure on Twitter to force them to reverse this censorship? It’s unlikely, but worth a shot.

See below for some of my reporting on the issue of Nazis in Ukraine and how they have been integrated into that country’s armed forces.

Palestine is Still the Issue is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Click image to read the full article.
Palestine is Still the Issue
Who are Ukraine's "Moderate Rebels?"
Russia’s president Vladimir Putin announced a new military operation in Ukraine on Thursday. The invasion is focusing on the heavily Russian populated Donbass region in the south-east of the country. In a dramatic speech, Putin announced it came after “Ukrainian aggression” and requests to …
Read more
a year ago · 4 likes · 1 comment · Asa Winstanley
Palestine is Still the Issue
How Israel is arming Ukrainian Nazis - #40
Since just before Christmas, there’s been a lot of hype in the capitalist press about Russia supposedly planning an invasion of Ukraine. Shades of Tony Blair’s infamous lie that Saddam Hussein’s “weapons of mass destruction” could be deployed within 45 minutes. Hardly anyone seems to be buying the pretext …
Read more
a year ago · 7 likes · Asa Winstanley
18
Share this post

Twitter is censoring reporting on Ukrainian Nazis on the pretext of "abusive behavior"

asawinstanley.substack.com
Previous
Next
18 Comments
Notan E. Moprog
Mar 11, 2022

Guess leftwingers should've listened to Glenn Greenwald when he told you many times and in no uncertain terms that censorship by the Big Tech won't stop with the so-called "nazis", guess it's time for you to open a Gab account

Expand full comment
Reply
Andy
Mar 11, 2022

Delete the tweet and move on. You won’t win the appeal and Twitter will keep you locked out.

Expand full comment
Reply
16 more comments…
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Asa Winstanley
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing