26 Comments
Oct 7Liked by Asa Winstanley

"Look what you made me do!" is a favorite trope among abusers and Zionists.

Expand full comment
Oct 7Liked by Asa Winstanley

An excellent and very comprehensive report which must be shared (and discussed) as widely as possible. Well done Asa for putting this together.

Expand full comment
Oct 7Liked by Asa Winstanley

Ever since it became apparent to me that the Zionists killed their own citizens on Oct 7, I have wondered about the true numbers of casualties attributed to Hamas. That the Israeli authorities lie about Oct 7 is consistent with their lying about practically everything else. But it looks like we will never know. Still, it is surprising that the Zionists put up the dead cars as an attraction when we now come to learn that most if not all were the product of Israeli gunship fire. Astounding!

Expand full comment

Excellent autopsy of an unnamed butchery orchestrated by the Zionist apparatus of repression, which reveals, if need be, the cynicism, machiavellianism, cruelty and contempt for human life expressed by the Israeli occupation forces, all things that the international community refuses to consider with the required honesty...

Expand full comment
Oct 7Liked by Asa Winstanley

Outstanding journalism! Thank you!!

Expand full comment
Oct 8Liked by Asa Winstanley

Big eye-opener and very comprehensive. Hats off to the amazing work you've done Asa

Expand full comment

Thank you Asa. I just finished watching Katie & Aaron on Monday Mourning and decided to devout my day listening to excellant journalism such as yours.

Expand full comment

Superb work! Saddest year anniv. show of E.I. So hard. Please cover the abduction of Am. citizen journalist Jeremy Loffredo & how to get #state dept to issue an intervention to release him, get him back. Journalism is not a crime. 1-888-407-4747. asap!

Expand full comment

True and now NYTs has revealed that Israel knew of the Hamas plan 2 years in advance. !!!! Let that sink in. This means the Biden Administration must have also known. U.S. and Israel Intel share and interact in regards to Intel. My suspicious, but obvious guess, is that Israel had people inside Hamas, as informants -just as the FBI does in the States, and futhermore, may have even been active participants in the planning and actions. Netanyahu and his Government and Military wanted this attack, the taking of hostages and murders to take place, in order to “finish” the job - the final solution to take every inch of what was left of Palestine as an entity and as a People. This is what the U.S. and Great Britain wanted and are aiding and abetting, along with Germany and until now- France. Even Sweden has provided weapons and perhaps other Nations. What a “killing” the Arms and Bombs industry are making.

Expand full comment

Correct that Israel and The US knew, but the information was provided by Egyptian intelligence, they have stated they knew in 2022 that the attack was being planned. They provided details of where the attack would come from and what was to be targeted. Perhaps the fact the rave was located there and that peoples in the kibbutz were rotated out to be replaced with more left leaning liberal Jews, the rave also attracted a more liberal crowd. Netanyahu would find that amusing and useful.

Expand full comment

On top of killing the Abraham accords the attack brought Israel’s apartheid and genocidal regime into the spotlight. The world had accepted Israel’s slow killing of Palestinians and its ethnic cleansing and the goals behind the illegal settlements in the West Bank, but now it’s been plain as day what Israel has been doing since 1948 and it no longer accepts it. We didn’t see millions of people protesting against Israel until it started its murderous rampage across Palestine.

Today Kamala repeated all the lies about what Hamas did even though every one of them have been debunked! Shame on her for continuing to give Israel the excuse to mass murder.

Expand full comment

Sadly the duplicitous Israeli narrative continues to dominate due to complicit Western media.

Expand full comment

Eye opening! There should be a breakdown of the death toll: number killed by Hamas vs their own military. Firstly,huge failure on the part of Israel to protect its people. It even even mass murdered them, not to mention it's citizens preferred to be killed by their own soldiers rather than risk being captured by Hamas. Why is this not being discussed and analyzed on mainstream media? No one is urging the Israeli's to conduct an investigation on the death toll and the crimes committed on Oct. 7th. It wasn't all Hamas.

Expand full comment

I am truly amazed at the depth of precision and data gathering. I believe that several other specs would deserve the same observation, and that the whole may be packed into a huge thesis.

That Israel killed its own citizens is one spec. I would suggest as well the truth about Palestinians weaponry capabilities (and Palestinian's use of weapons as well), since 1970. This would illustrate the same kind of narrative shift.

We may observe as well the Palestinian resistance movements, in order to show how the Hamas is actually not much some "Palestinian representatives". We would end up seeing that stone throwing is a marginal spec for Palestinians, and that their true resistance is actually spiritual, writing, and how they identified the true obstacle, namely a wall between them and the rest of the world, at the informational level.

You may want to create a sub-section: "what-to-do-with-all-of-this", gathering all your precious works. At some point in time, people and journalist will be able to gain much time with such a tightly packed structure already existing.

Thank you Asa W. for having been reporting the Palestinian situation with accuracy. I recently

tried to bind several of the above points in an article that I posted, and your name came back several time. You're on the hit for a while now, it's great as a human to understand that a positive human voice is around.

Expand full comment

Hello Asa and readers, I'm blocked from this account https://www.damiancounsell.com/p/blood-libel-and-ordinary-libel which details a comment from me linking to Asa's rumble account of Oct 7th.

I'd be grateful is you could clarify how 'blood libel' is being egregiously and disgustingly used to justify the murder of Palestinian children.

Many thanks,

Jo

Expand full comment

Truly great and courageous jouralism, this. Many thanks.

Expand full comment

Vivian Silver was a renowned Canadian peace activist who lived in Kibbutz Be’eri. Her remains were identified (and not burned beyond recognition by Hamas!) in mid November 2023 around the same time Israel changed their Oct 7th '1400 killed' narrative to 'about 1200', a number which still stands today.

Ms Silver's death was mentioned in the NYTimes, Washington Post, the Guardian and around the world. A touching obit appeared in the Economist. It was also revealing: "She was typing in a cupboard in her safe room; the terrorists had now barged in."

Call me crazy, but I think Vivian Silver may have been killed by the same Israeli tank shell that incinerated the Hamas terrorists and everybody else nearby.

Expand full comment